Oct 28, 2012
Columbus Crew
2 - 1
Aug 22, 2012
Columbus Crew
2 - 1
Mar 31, 2012
Toronto FC
0 - 1
Sep 10, 2011
Columbus Crew
2 - 4
Apr 23, 2011
Toronto FC
1 - 1
Oct 16, 2010
Toronto FC
2 - 2
Mar 27, 2010
Columbus Crew
2 - 0
Jul 25, 2009
Columbus Crew
3 - 2
May 2, 2009
Toronto FC
1 - 1
Mar 28, 2009
Columbus Crew
1 - 1
Sep 13, 2008
Toronto FC
1 - 1
May 17, 2008
Toronto FC
0 - 0
Mar 29, 2008
Columbus Crew
2 - 0
Sep 22, 2007
Toronto FC
1 - 2
Jul 22, 2007
Columbus Crew
2 - 0
May 26, 2007
Columbus Crew
2 - 2